MLB Trade Rumors Member Posts

 

Donnie12's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded


Donnie12's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Donnie12's Posts

 

 

To Donnie12's last 5 rumours posts

 

To Donnie12's last 5 rumour replies

 

Donnie12's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Donnie12's rumours posts

 

15 May 2015 14:58:49
With the two first round pick in this years mlb first player draft the Detroit Tigers selected what 2 prospects

I'm thinking LHP Tyler Jay from Illinois and then Joe McCarthy OF from Virgina

Donnie12

1.) Who will the Tigers Pick then


2.) How is this a trade rumor?


3.) It seems you are having a conversation with yourself.


4.) Nevermind, since another person said something. Also its interesting that Crazysull disappears and Donnie has reappeared.


5.) I'm not Crazyskull K I'm Donnie and I'm have been at school trying to finish up k


6.) Just seems rather convenient that the two of you (if there are two of you) are never on here at the same time.


7.) I really don't no who crazyskull is really I don't watch how ever is on here I only get on here when i'm at school and i'm in school right now


8.) 18 May 2015 19:58:10
So, Donnie, when's 5th grade graduation?


9.) RHP Phil Bickford and LHP Juan Hillman


 

 

16 Apr 2015 19:55:32
Tigers

Sign Price&Cespedes to contract extensions
Sign Rafael Soriano to a 2yr deal
release Nathan

Trade Hernan Perez and a ptbnl to the cubs for Kris Bryant to play 3rd base with Castellanos

C(Avila, McCann)
1st(Cabrera)
2nd(Kinsler)
SS (Iglesias)
3b(casellanos, Bryant)
LF(Cespedes)
CF(Gose, Davis)
RF(Martinez)
DH(V.Martinez)

Donnie12

1.) Obvious troll is obvious.


2.) Just awful


3.) If the Tigers were unable to resign Scherzer, what makes you think the will resign they will resign Price? Cespedes isn't going to sign one either. And obviously you are serious on that trade.


4.) Yes I'm serious on the tradex


5.) 17 Apr 2015 16:10:52
So let me get this straight.

You honestly believe that Detroit will 1) actually obtain Kris Bryant in a trade, 2) they will get him for a guy like Hernan Perez, who is really, really bad. 3) A Player to be named later. (Is that PTBNL Miguel Cabrera?) and 4) and this one is the best. you are going to platoon Kris Bryant with Nick Castellanos.

Donnie, are you aware of who Kris Bryant is?


6.) Donnie, are you at all related to Crazysull?


7.) 18 Apr 2015 00:03:07
Batman, Crazysull hasn't been around forever. Maybe he is Crazysull.


8.) Thats what I was thinking after I posted it.


9.) I'm not Crazysull I don't even know who that is and I think the tigers will sign Price and Cespedes to contact extensions


10.) 20 Apr 2015 19:13:01
Donnie, I'm curious on your Bryant idea. You can't possibly think that's a good idea. Please justify it.


11.) Natedub the tigers are the worst farm system in the league right now they have to do something to bring it up. Bryant is better then Perez and Romine and will be a great player for the tigers


12.) 23 Apr 2015 07:51:28
You're missing the point. how on earth can you justify that the Tigers would be able to land Kris Bryant?

There's a 0.000000000000001% that the Tigers could ever land Bryant. and if they did. Cabrera would be in a Cubs uni after the trade.


13.) ^^Ok you're clearly not crazysull, donnie. Your much worse. That has to be the worst reasoning for a trade I ever heard on here.


14.) Another point donnie. You say the Tigers have the worst farm system in baseball, which is very true, but you want them to trade for a guy who could bring it up, but how can they trade for him when they have nothing to give? You didn't explain a thing. And even adding Bryant will not improve their farm system. Its just one guy. You need multiple prospects.


15.) Hey guys I am back and thanks for letting me know that I am not the worst on this site. And you guys are missing a big point

He said that Bryant would boost the Tigers farm system yet his plan is to platoon him at third in the big leagues?
How can a guy in the MLB strength the Triple-A team?
And if he is in the minors the deal would hurt the farm system because based off this trade they would be giving up a "prospect" and be losing a minor leaguer and I doubt the guy is so bad that kissing him would make the team better


16.) Also the fact is that along with a tigers star going to the Cubs in a Bryant deal I think Castilanos would have to go to the Cubs as well and help Olt out at the hot corner there but there is no way in hell this deal will ever happen and it doesn't need to either I think of Detroit as the Natinals of the American League and one only decent player won't hurt them given all the talent that they have got


 

 

08 Apr 2015 15:45:36
Detroit tigers trades and fa signings

The only fas that was victor Martinez 4yrs/68m

Then the trades there were a lot of trades so we got Alfredo Simon for Suarez and Crawford and then we got Shane Greene for Robby Ray and A minor then we got Gose for Travis then the Big trade that happened was yoenis Cespedes and Alex Wilson and a minor named Gabe for Rick Porcello

Donnie12

1.) Ok is there a point to this?


2.) Yes there is I think with the moves that the Tigers have done they can win it all


3.) The Tigers are actually weaker this year than last. Good luck with that.


4.) Not with that bullpen.


5.) 08 Apr 2015 21:05:24
I don't know if I can say they weaker. Cespedes is an upgrade (although I would never have given up Porcello for him). Plus, they have Iglesias back.

However, they made zero improvements on their bullpen.


6.) And the rotation is weak past the first three slots, with little depth in sight.

Overall, I think weaker. Time will tell.


7.) What r u guys talking about all the tigers need to do is sign Rafael soriano then the tigers bullpen will be great the bullpen will have Soriano,Chamberlain,Soria,
Gozelanny,Nesbitt,Albuquerque that's a bullpen for u


8.) 09 Apr 2015 17:03:10
Donnie. so Soriano will walk in and all the other bullpen guys will suddenly become amazing? Yeah, not buying it.


9.) They are not a bad team at all, keep in mind they got iglesias back, so they actually have a shortstop now. Gose looked pretty good last night. Cespedes is a huge upgrade for them. Really they lost Scherzer and Porcello and that's it for the most part. Anytime you have a team with Cabrera, JD and Victor, Kinsler, Cespedes, and Price, your are going to win games.


10.) Thank u Gpack17 for Backing me up I know that the tigers are a great team I'm a tigers fan and I think the need to get Soriano


11.) A great team? No. How many World Series titles have they won in the last 6-7 years?

Are they a good team? Yes. They'll do well this year.

Are they weaker than last year? I think so. Beyond Price and Sanchez, the rotation is a big question mark. And, the bullpen is among the weakest in baseball. Plus, the team is beginning to get old. I think in three years the Tigers may be the AL version of the Phillies.


12.) K LongtimeBaseballFan in the next 3 yrs I don't c the tigers even being a version of the Phillis and the tigers Have a great time and also they have some good young players in the Minors like Magglio JR Derek Hill whit mayberry, Artie Lewicki Joey Pankake, Spencer Turnbull do u get what I'm saying


13.) I get what you're saying, Donnie. You are blinded by homerism. When was the last Detroit hitter that panned out for them? Avisail Garcia? Traded to White Sox and very average. Nick Castellanos? Meh. Anyone else?

They have Verlander and Miggy and VMart, which take up a huge portion of the payroll. Price will leave as a free agent. What's the plan then?

90 wins this year, and a likely playoff flame-out. Again.

Look at the two teams in the World Series last year. Deep, great bullpens. Now look at your team and tell me you like what you see.


14.) What the hell r u talking about LongtimeBaseballFan if u know the tigers like I do then u know were I'm coming from. The tigers have a Awesome team need one or two more pieces in the bullpen that's it


15.) Donnie, good luck with that.


16.) 09 Apr 2015 23:41:09
Verlander, Martinez, Kinsler, Cabrera, Sanchez. all signed to huge contracts through 2017 or later. none of them are getting younger.

The AL version the Phillies. no doubt.


17.) Joba isn't a very good pitcher, flamed out in New York, did terrible the second half of last year. Soriano seemed to have lost it at the end of the year. Just because they hypothetically sign one guy doesn't mean the rest of the guys would do much better as LBF stated. They are a good team, but older. Their rotation isn't as good as once was. Verlander is not what he use to be. Who knows how Greene will do in his second year and Simon I really don't know about him. Cespedes and Price are free agents at the end of the Year. Price will definitely test the market. Cespedes may also. And Great would imply they have won the World Series in the past, as LBF said also. And Donnie, I can see the Tigers being the Phillies 3 or 4 years from now. They are getting older, they DON'T have a great farm system at all its in the bottom of most/all rankings, as they have traded what few prospects they have to win now, with the exception of a few. Sounds exactly like what the Phillies have done.


18.) The Tigers are a great team don't u c they set the Al record with the most scoreless innings with 24 They have a awesome rotation and they have great defense They aren't even close to being the AL version of the Phillies


19.) 1. Price, Sanchez. then who? Verlander is not as good as he use to be.
2. Aging players.
3. They have big contracts.
4. Little to nothing in the farm system.
5. Bullpen not good.
Exactly like the Phillies downhill fall a few years back. They trade what they had to win now. Its not coming back to bite them yet, but it will.
They aren't a bad team, no one is disagreeing with you on that.


20.) 10 Apr 2015 17:31:49
Donnie, your being a fan is blinding you from what we are trying to say.

The reason they are getting close to being the Phillies is this:

In 2017, the following Tigers will be owed the following money, and I'll put their age next to the total:

Cabrera- $28M (35)
Verlander- $28M (35)
VMart- $18M (39)
Sanchez- $16.8M (34)
Kinsler- $11M (36)
+6M being paid to Texas for Prince Fielder.

They'll owe $107.8 million to 5 players aged 34 or older and one player on another team.

Keep in mind, they're 2015 payroll is around $170M. so you're looking at 63% of your payroll being swept up by 5 guys. and you still haven't touched the arbitration contracts of JD Martinez, Jose Iglesias, Nick Castellanos. and you haven't considered that they'll have limited money to work with to sign free agents and stay under the luxury cap.

The point is this: IF YOU READ NOTHING ELSE, READ THIS:

The reason they are the Phillies is because they have contracts out to really old players for several years. Any injuries or decline in talent only makes them worse. They'll have a beast of time trading off VMart when he can't play anymore. Think Ryan Howard's situation in Philly. Heck, that's probably Verlander for Detroit at this point.

Detroit will be far better, record wise, than the Phillies. but they are a year or two away from being in the same spot.


 

 

 

Donnie12 has no Banter Posts

 

 

Donnie12's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

I really don't no who crazyskull is really I don't watch how ever is on here I only get on here when i'm at school and i'm in school right now

Donnie12

 

 

Click To View This Thread

I'm not Crazyskull K I'm Donnie and I'm have been at school trying to finish up k

Donnie12

 

 

Click To View This Thread

Who will the Tigers Pick then

Donnie12

 

 

Click To View This Thread

Natedub the tigers are the worst farm system in the league right now they have to do something to bring it up. Bryant is better then Perez and Romine and will be a great player for the tigers

Donnie12

 

 

Click To View This Thread

I would like to get anyone of them Hammel would be great, Wilson is ok and I would love to bring back Fister but the tigers r giving up to much for each guy

Donnie12

 

 

 

Donnie12 has no Banter Replies